Jovanni reverse interview w/ Lia Tarachansky - Ep 166
Fortress On A Hill (FOH) PodcastJanuary 22, 2025x
166
01:02:2557.14 MB

Jovanni reverse interview w/ Lia Tarachansky - Ep 166

Don:

this is Fortress On A Hill, with Henri, Danny, Kaygan, Jo

Don:

vonni, Shiloh, Monisha , and Mike

Henri:

Welcome everyone to Fortress On A Hill, a podcast about U.

Henri:

S.

Henri:

foreign policy, anti imperialism, skepticism, and the American way of war.

Henri:

I'm Henri.

Henri:

Thank you for joining us today.

Henri:

, this is a non Henri episode I'm introducing here., in today's episode,

Henri:

revisiting a conversation between Jovanni and returning guest, Lia

Henri:

Tarachansky recorded on November 6, 2024, just a day after the U.

Henri:

S.

Henri:

elections.

Henri:

This time, Lia is taking the lead as the interviewer, and Jovanni has

Henri:

graciously offered to be the interviewee.

Henri:

Since this recording happened, the geopolitical landscape of our world

Henri:

has undergone significant changes.

Henri:

We witnessed Israel's failed attempt to invade southern Lebanon for the

Henri:

sixth time in its history, after 57 hard fought days of successful

Henri:

repelling from Hezbollah, followed by the collapse of the Syrian state after

Henri:

a decade of an international dirty war waged against it, which profoundly

Henri:

impacting the dynamics in West Asia and among coalition resistance members.

Henri:

A ceasefire has been implemented in Gaza, bringing a temporary

Henri:

respite to that conflict.

Henri:

We've also seen the inauguration of President Trump, and in a surprising move,

Henri:

The outgoing Biden administration's ban on the popular social media platform TikTok.

Henri:

To return to Gaza for just a moment, on January 19, 2025, a long awaited

Henri:

ceasefire in Gaza finally took effect, albeit after some initial delays

Henri:

and further Israeli aggression.

Henri:

This agreement aims to halt hostilities and facilitate the

Henri:

release of Israeli captives held by militants in Gaza, as well as

Henri:

Palestinians held captive by Israel.

Henri:

And finally, but certainly not minimally, on January 20th, which is the 22nd as I

Henri:

speak right now, on the 20th of January of this year, 2025, Donald Trump was

Henri:

sworn in as the 47th president of the US.

Henri:

This marked a return to power for Trump, who has promised swift action

Henri:

on various policy fronts, and that is what the news is filled with right now.

Henri:

So I'm sure we'll have more coming out on the podcast on this front

Henri:

in particular in the near future.

Henri:

for a little background on today's episode in this intimate conversation,

Henri:

Lia delves deep into Jovanni's personal political landscape, exploring the

Henri:

roots of his political consciousness, his profound connection to West Asia,

Henri:

his military background, and the intergenerational dialogue of anti

Henri:

imperialism he shares with his son.

Henri:

Through a nuanced and personal lens, Jovanni offers insights into how his

Henri:

experiences have shaped his understanding of global political dynamics.

Henri:

Without further ado, let's dive into this interview between Lia and Jovanni.

Henri:

Enjoy.

Henri:

Thanks, folks.

Jovanni:

Welcome, everyone, to Fortress On A Hill, a podcast about U.

Jovanni:

S.

Jovanni:

foreign policy, anti imperialism, skepticism, and the American way of war.

Jovanni:

I'm Jovanni, your host.

Jovanni:

Thank you for being with us today.

Jovanni:

Today, we're going to do something different.

Jovanni:

I'm excited to have a special guest with me.

Jovanni:

Returning guest, Lia is an acclaimed journalist and filmmaker known for

Jovanni:

her compelling narratives on complex issues, particularly surrounding

Jovanni:

the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Jovanni:

In this episode, Lia will guide our conversation diving into my

Jovanni:

thoughts and experiences while exploring her unique insights.

Jovanni:

As a returning guest, she'll bring a wealth of knowledge and perspective

Jovanni:

that I'm eager to share with you all.

Jovanni:

So without further ado, let's welcome Lia and see what this

Jovanni:

conversation will take us to.

Jovanni:

Lia, how are you today?

Lia Tarachansky:

I'm great, how are you?

Jovanni:

How about those elections?

Jovanni:

How did Canada receive them?

Lia Tarachansky:

For our listeners, today is the day after the American elections.

Lia Tarachansky:

I'm based in Toronto in Canada where the average Canadian is glued

Lia Tarachansky:

to the television watching what happens in your country because

Lia Tarachansky:

of course it impacts us very much.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I guess I just wanted to start with today and then

Lia Tarachansky:

we're going to go a little bit.

Lia Tarachansky:

Back in time.

Lia Tarachansky:

Tell me, I know that partisan politics is not exactly your focus when you say

Lia Tarachansky:

that you are a political person, but as an American, how does it feel to now

Lia Tarachansky:

live in the second Trump presidency?

Jovanni:

There's a lot of mixed feelings with it.

Jovanni:

I don't support neither of the parties, but we have a two party

Jovanni:

system that pretty much they're controlled by the same donors.

Jovanni:

Not too long ago the CEO of BlackRock, which is a financial firm here,

Jovanni:

a global financial firm openly stated that it doesn't matter who

Jovanni:

wins, nothing will change for them.

Jovanni:

And they're supporting both sides, both parties.

Jovanni:

So at the structural level things seems to be running the same at the

Jovanni:

domestic level there may be a lot of changes, most of the people that I

Jovanni:

talk to that I organize around fear a second Trump presidency with the issues

Jovanni:

Of migrant rights LGBTQ rights other marginalized people in the United States.

Jovanni:

However looking at how the Dems behaved the last four years when the

Jovanni:

students universities protested the genocide in Palestine, the Dems,

Jovanni:

behaved the same way that they're saying that Trump will behave.

Jovanni:

The police were sicced on them.

Jovanni:

There were pepper spray.

Jovanni:

There were beating.

Jovanni:

There were push out at the universities.

Jovanni:

People were blacklisted.

Jovanni:

The universities there were I personally know of people whose children went to

Jovanni:

university at UT and they graduated and because they protested, they held their

Jovanni:

degrees, and they were holding on to them because they were arrested in the

Jovanni:

protests and whatnot, so when it comes to realism, how real things happen in

Jovanni:

the world, in the United States, when We become a threat to establishments, we

Jovanni:

become a threat to profits and whatnot.

Jovanni:

Both parties will behave the same way, in my view.

Jovanni:

And because

Lia Tarachansky:

of that, you don't think that Trump winning

Lia Tarachansky:

is this huge catastrophic drop in democracy that people call it?

Jovanni:

No, because one of the things that people say about

Jovanni:

Trump is that, what you get.

Jovanni:

One of the first, when I was in high school, I was really radicalized by first

Jovanni:

reading about Malcolm X, malcolm X pretty much radicalized me in American politics.

Jovanni:

I came from Puerto Rico in the late eighties, early nineties,

Jovanni:

and then one of the things that was introduced to was Malcolm X.

Jovanni:

And one of the things he talked about the American elections, and this is very good.

Jovanni:

There's a very good speech that he made called the Battle of the Bullet, which I

Jovanni:

tend to listen to every election cycle.

Jovanni:

One of the things he talks about is, when he describes the Democrats

Jovanni:

and the Republicans, he states that the Republicans and the Democrats

Jovanni:

are like the wolves and the fox.

Jovanni:

The wolf are the Republicans, the fox are the Democrats, right?

Jovanni:

The wolf, when he shows you his teeth, he tells you what he's going

Jovanni:

to do, he tells you his intention.

Jovanni:

When he shows you his teeth, he's going to eat you.

Jovanni:

However, the fox wind and dine you first before he shows you his teeth,

Jovanni:

so that's really my approach on the partisan politics my thing is mostly

Jovanni:

on the ground is talking to people on the ground, organizing on the ground,

Jovanni:

education on the ground and yeah.

Lia Tarachansky:

So let's bring down those big ideological statements to

Lia Tarachansky:

the nitty gritty of everyday life.

Lia Tarachansky:

When you say, I'm organizing.

Lia Tarachansky:

Let's pretend that you're speaking to a person who doesn't know you

Lia Tarachansky:

and is not from the activist world.

Lia Tarachansky:

Can you tell us what exactly do you mean when you say I'm organizing?

Jovanni:

Mostly organizing getting people out some of the things that I've been

Jovanni:

involved here is it helped out in the housing issues with people here with

Jovanni:

affordable housing people, and pretty much getting people to come out, getting people

Jovanni:

to pressure their city council there's this housing unit nearby, in the city

Jovanni:

that they're trying to get people out.

Jovanni:

To get torn down because they want to build a baseball stadium, and it's one

Jovanni:

of the few affordable housing, mixed income housing areas in the city.

Jovanni:

So mainly we go around, talking to people, getting people to come out.

Jovanni:

Most people feel comfortable.

Jovanni:

They have no voice.

Jovanni:

They feel impotent.

Jovanni:

They feel that they can't do much about it.

Jovanni:

But, you start talking to people, you start networking with other people,

Jovanni:

you start educating people, flying, sending flowers and everything.

Jovanni:

Get more people out.

Jovanni:

Get people to call their city council.

Jovanni:

Get people to show up at the city council meetings and whatnot.

Jovanni:

We'll put pressure on it.

Jovanni:

Get the press out, the newspaper out, the local papers out.

Jovanni:

I started interviewing people and it brings out a lot of things out

Jovanni:

to light that the local politicians put pressure on local politicians

Jovanni:

that they can't really operate.

Jovanni:

They can't really operate.

Lia Tarachansky:

So

Jovanni:

when you say

Lia Tarachansky:

you're organizing and presumably this is something

Lia Tarachansky:

you think other people should be doing with their free time.

Lia Tarachansky:

What you're saying is that you're involved in municipal politics,

Lia Tarachansky:

local politics, you're getting involved in the local media.

Lia Tarachansky:

Is that what you mean by organizing?

Jovanni:

Yes.

Lia Tarachansky:

Okay, so when we look at the two party system

Lia Tarachansky:

of America, obviously I'm not an American, but I had the opportunity

Lia Tarachansky:

to live in America in Washington, D.

Lia Tarachansky:

C.

Lia Tarachansky:

for almost a year and in Brooklyn for a long time, and in that time,

Lia Tarachansky:

I got to see America under George W.

Lia Tarachansky:

Bush and America under And that's the story of America.

Lia Tarachansky:

During the first Obama election.

Lia Tarachansky:

And what I noticed is that a Democratic president tends

Lia Tarachansky:

to pacify the American left.

Lia Tarachansky:

What do you think if this second Trump administration could light the

Lia Tarachansky:

fire under the feet of the kind of establishment American left, what

Lia Tarachansky:

do you think they should be doing?

Lia Tarachansky:

And what are the actions?

Lia Tarachansky:

In what way should they organize in order to fundamentally create the structural

Lia Tarachansky:

changes that you wish would happen?

Jovanni:

Yeah so I recall, I remember those days that you were talking about.

Jovanni:

I remember that during the Bush years, there were a lot of protests out.

Jovanni:

There were I think it was the largest protest.

Jovanni:

Of a war that hadn't really started yet, which was the Iraq war.

Jovanni:

There were like millions of people in the streets.

Jovanni:

They were, when they run up to the war back in 2002 and 2003.

Jovanni:

And they were constantly protesting bullshitting everything.

Jovanni:

But as soon as Obama came to power, everybody just went home.

Jovanni:

Everybody just went home and it was hard to get people out to protest the Iraq war,

Jovanni:

even though the Iraq war was still going.

Jovanni:

They were expanding.

Jovanni:

It was hard for people to get out because they didn't want

Jovanni:

to undermine Obama, right?

Jovanni:

And exactly that's the same thing.

Jovanni:

I saw the same thing now with this recent election now.

Jovanni:

Many of the people that were out there protesting, against the genocide in

Jovanni:

Palestine, as soon as we got close to the elections they went home and

Jovanni:

then they became to door knock for Kamala Harris, to go knocking, to

Jovanni:

try to get her elected and whatnot.

Jovanni:

So yeah that I don't know, it's very weird to me.

Jovanni:

It's very schizophrenic to me.

Jovanni:

But yeah, you're absolutely right.

Jovanni:

Usually when there's a Republican in power people tend to come

Jovanni:

out more, be more vocal.

Jovanni:

I remember when the last Trump presidency was here, when he issued

Jovanni:

the Muslim ban, I remember people would go into the airport, for example.

Jovanni:

They invaded the airport and they occupied the airport for a long time

Jovanni:

here in the city and everything.

Jovanni:

There were a lot of movements, a lot of actions, people in the streets.

Jovanni:

But yeah, you're absolutely right.

Jovanni:

And do

Lia Tarachansky:

you feel that those direct actions precipitated fundamental

Lia Tarachansky:

structural change in the country?

Jovanni:

I don't know, a side of me tells me that the ruling people

Jovanni:

or people of the ruling class don't really care, they ignore us, they

Jovanni:

continue doing what they're doing.

Jovanni:

Because you saw what happened here, because all this pressure,

Jovanni:

because coming up to this election, Despite, hearing that the policies

Jovanni:

in Palestine and Israel was going to harm the election, they didn't care.

Jovanni:

They continued going with it.

Jovanni:

They were told that this policy of, just giving open reins to

Jovanni:

Israel to do whatever it wants.

Jovanni:

Was going to harm their elections.

Jovanni:

They just didn't do a U turn.

Jovanni:

They continue going with it.

Jovanni:

They hope for the best, tells me that they just ignore.

Jovanni:

People, but even if

Lia Tarachansky:

people get organized, it doesn't necessarily

Lia Tarachansky:

mean that they cause change.

Lia Tarachansky:

What kind of change do you think needs to happen for there to be

Lia Tarachansky:

a fundamental restructuring of access to social justice and social

Lia Tarachansky:

securities in the United States?

Jovanni:

One of the big changes that has to be pushed is the fact

Jovanni:

that so much money influenced our elected leaders, right?

Jovanni:

And they're beholden more a donor class than their own constituent.

Jovanni:

They're willing to sacrifice their constituent in order to

Jovanni:

not to alienate their donors.

Jovanni:

That's one of the big things that needs to happen that to be a cap

Jovanni:

on how much money people could get.

Jovanni:

And there's always a way to get around it.

Jovanni:

But that's one of the big things that needs to change, Because like maybe

Jovanni:

Ronnie said, business are people too, or capital is for people as well.

Jovanni:

So their speech tends to be louder than the speech of the constituents.

Jovanni:

That's one of the big things that needs to change in order

Jovanni:

for anything else to change too.

Jovanni:

The imperial politics, most American activists that I speak to don't really

Jovanni:

think outside of the borders, right?

Jovanni:

We're talking about how people reacted to Trumps in Canada and whatnot.

Jovanni:

What happens in the United States affects the whole world.

Jovanni:

The elections in the United States do affect other people.

Jovanni:

A lot of activists that I speak to tend to not see beyond the

Jovanni:

borders of the United States.

Jovanni:

We have to have a more internationalist perspective.

Jovanni:

Juan Perón in Argentina said that the real politics are international politics.

Jovanni:

Everything else is administration.

Jovanni:

So in order to reel in, we have to reel in the imperial

Jovanni:

structure of this country, right?

Jovanni:

We have to, not spend so much money on wars.

Jovanni:

And on fun in this war,

Lia Tarachansky:

so reducing the defense budget, restructuring

Lia Tarachansky:

the way elections happen.

Lia Tarachansky:

Anything else that you think people could actually getting people involved

Lia Tarachansky:

in direct democracy like in Switzerland.

Lia Tarachansky:

You've been interviewing me about my films from Israel and

Lia Tarachansky:

Palestine for about a decade.

Lia Tarachansky:

You and I actually met when I was touring on the side of the road in Texas.

Lia Tarachansky:

And you talked about Israel and Palestine quite a lot today, and I

Lia Tarachansky:

was just wondering, considering what's going on in Bangladesh, considering

Lia Tarachansky:

what's going on in Saudi and in Sudan and Ukraine, why do you think Israel

Lia Tarachansky:

and Palestine is so central to you?

Lia Tarachansky:

And why do you think Americans have to center it?

Lia Tarachansky:

Why do you think Americans have to care about this particular place

Lia Tarachansky:

and this particular conflict?

Jovanni:

Because it's, one thing, it's in your face.

Jovanni:

It's been going on for a long time.

Jovanni:

For 75 years now the displacement of these people and today, it's so gross.

Jovanni:

It's in your face.

Jovanni:

It's right, right in front of you.

Jovanni:

And it seems that no matter, like you mentioned Bangladesh, the

Jovanni:

coup in Bangladesh recently.

Jovanni:

But this particular conflict is so gross.

Jovanni:

It's so obscene.

Jovanni:

It's so in your face.

Jovanni:

And the leadership that we have, just straight up lie in front of

Jovanni:

you, in the press conference and openly, they just don't care very

Jovanni:

disgracefully, very shamefully.

Jovanni:

That brings out, that internationalizes.

Jovanni:

This conflict, it's just not in one, it's not You could

Lia Tarachansky:

argue, but you could argue in the Congo, six million

Lia Tarachansky:

people have died in absolutely gross and very brutal ways.

Lia Tarachansky:

Six million people, right?

Lia Tarachansky:

All the people who died in Palestine put together on all the sides

Lia Tarachansky:

don't amount to 100, 000 people.

Lia Tarachansky:

So six million died in Congo and yet, why do you think Americans should

Lia Tarachansky:

care about Israel and Palestine as much as you care about it?

Jovanni:

Going back to how it's in front of you right now.

Jovanni:

You can open any social media.

Jovanni:

You see what's happening in Palestine.

Jovanni:

Most Americans don't see what's happening in the Congo.

Jovanni:

Don't see what's happening in Bangladesh.

Jovanni:

It's not that it's less just not as in your face as the

Jovanni:

situation in Palestine it is.

Jovanni:

So it's

Lia Tarachansky:

the hypocrisy that gets to you.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Jovanni:

The hypocrisy behind it.

Lia Tarachansky:

I see, and speaking of hypocrisy, you are born in Puerto Rico.

Lia Tarachansky:

I think you're born in Brooklyn, I'm sorry, but you

Lia Tarachansky:

grew up in Puerto Rico, right?

Lia Tarachansky:

I am not an American.

Lia Tarachansky:

I don't know that much about American history, but when I first learned about

Lia Tarachansky:

Puerto Rico, it was one of the most shocking lessons of American history.

Lia Tarachansky:

What did you learn?

Lia Tarachansky:

What do you think Americans should know, the average continental American

Lia Tarachansky:

should know about Puerto Rico?

Lia Tarachansky:

Puerto Rico

Jovanni:

is a colony.

Jovanni:

It's a colony.

Jovanni:

They had a name change in 1952 to a commonwealth, but it's still a colony.

Jovanni:

People say commonwealth of Puerto Rico, but Australia is a commonwealth of the UK.

Jovanni:

And Virginia is also a commonwealth of Virginia.

Jovanni:

And Puerto Rico does not look like Virginia, it does not look like Australia.

Jovanni:

So you just dress it up with the name commonwealth, but what it is a colony.

Jovanni:

It's there to extract, it's there to, as a military position to, it used to be

Jovanni:

called the Keys to the Americas, or the Keys to the Caribbean, because the ways,

Jovanni:

geographically, the ways it's out there.

Jovanni:

You fortified, the Spaniards fortified, and then the Americans fortified, and

Jovanni:

the Americans used it to safeguard the Panama Canal, for example, when they

Jovanni:

were building it, and to keep European competitors out from the Americas.

Jovanni:

So that's the value of Puerto Rico to American imperialists, is its

Jovanni:

military value, and the extraction.

Jovanni:

But yeah, it's a colony.

Jovanni:

And

Lia Tarachansky:

when you're a colony, you always get the short edge of the stick.

Lia Tarachansky:

Is this part of the reason why you are focused on Palestine

Lia Tarachansky:

because of the colonial connection?

Jovanni:

Yes.

Jovanni:

Can you

Lia Tarachansky:

elaborate on that?

Jovanni:

So both Palestine.

Jovanni:

And Puerto Rico similarities.

Jovanni:

Originally with the British, a colonial outpost for the British,

Jovanni:

a strategic military point for the British to safeguard the canal

Jovanni:

and also to have a foot in the Middle East or in West Asia for the

Jovanni:

British, puerto Rico is the same way.

Jovanni:

Because of the geographical situation, it became a funnel to

Jovanni:

control traffic from Europe into the Americas for the Americans, or before

Jovanni:

the Spaniards, then the Americans.

Jovanni:

When the Americans were building the canal, it was a safeguard to

Jovanni:

intercept any type of threat to the canal, particularly in the First

Jovanni:

World War, with the Germans, and then the Second World War and whatnot.

Jovanni:

So both of them have, military strategic points.

Jovanni:

For the Americans, Puerto Rico was a point to the Americas.

Jovanni:

They call the Caribbean the Mediterranean of the Americas,

Jovanni:

from Puerto Rico, they can control the Caribbean, they control South

Jovanni:

America, close to South America.

Jovanni:

From Palestine, the British able to, control the Red Sea, the traffic

Jovanni:

going in and out through the Canal, have foot in West Asia with all the

Jovanni:

resources that are in West Asia so that's the big connection of it.

Jovanni:

The

Lia Tarachansky:

colonial international trade.

Lia Tarachansky:

That's very big picture, but in what way specifically did American colonialism

Lia Tarachansky:

impact your life as a Puerto Rican?

Lia Tarachansky:

How did it impact your specific life in Puerto Rico for Puerto Ricans?

Jovanni:

We have a spiritual connection with the land.

Jovanni:

We have identity connection with the land.

Jovanni:

We identify as Puerto Ricans, even though we've been an

Jovanni:

American colony for 120 years now.

Jovanni:

But we still identify as Puerto Rican and we still have a

Jovanni:

connection with the rest of America.

Jovanni:

We feel more in more in common with our next door neighbor, the

Jovanni:

Dominican Republic and Cubans than we do with Anglo America, for example.

Lia Tarachansky:

Culturally.

Jovanni:

Yeah, culturally, linguistically, historically

Lia Tarachansky:

and economically, is there any difference between

Lia Tarachansky:

living in Puerto Rico and living in mainland America?

Jovanni:

Yes.

Jovanni:

Yes, there's a whole lot of difference.

Jovanni:

The wages are different in mainland America than it is in Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

And it's interesting because Puerto Ricans also pay into Social Security

Jovanni:

just mainland Americans but they don't get the full benefits of Social

Jovanni:

Security like mainland Americans do.

Jovanni:

Even though Congress ultimately controls Puerto Rico, Congress controls all

Jovanni:

international territories or overseas territories of the United States, right?

Jovanni:

So we in the same status as Diego Garcia.

Jovanni:

Diego Garcia is an island in the Pacific, it doesn't have a population,

Jovanni:

it's just a military post there but we're in the same status in the sense

Jovanni:

that we are overseas territory, and we don't vote for the President of the

Jovanni:

United States, but we are impacted.

Jovanni:

By the decisions that are made here, for example we get recruited to go

Jovanni:

to wars as well, like Puerto Ricans, per capita died in the Vietnam War,

Jovanni:

and the Korean War, than any other ethnic group in the United States,

Lia Tarachansky:

and when we first met, I remember you were telling me about

Lia Tarachansky:

Puerto Rico, and I was so shocked by the hypocrisy of Puerto Rico being perceived

Lia Tarachansky:

in mainland America as just another state.

Lia Tarachansky:

And yet, your experience of moving from Puerto Rico to Texas, you were describing

Lia Tarachansky:

an experience that's very familiar for me, the experience of an immigrant.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I was just wondering if you wanted to talk a little bit about that, because it

Lia Tarachansky:

does seem like the average American does not see Puerto Rico as just another state.

Lia Tarachansky:

State or just another territory, but it's some kind of like exceptional

Lia Tarachansky:

place where for some reason it's okay that those people don't have

Lia Tarachansky:

the same rights as other Americans.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Jovanni:

So the most American, every American don't really realize don't realize

Jovanni:

that relationship that Puerto Ricans have with the United States.

Jovanni:

I still hear people asking us, asking Puerto Ricans if, if they

Jovanni:

have a green car, for example.

Jovanni:

They're, oh, they're how did you get here?

Jovanni:

Did you get a visa?

Jovanni:

So we still get comments like that.

Jovanni:

People don't really understand, don't really know the relationship

Jovanni:

of Puerto Rico because we're still seen as something foreign.

Jovanni:

There's

Lia Tarachansky:

a prevailing ignorance.

Jovanni:

Yeah, and we're seen as just a paradise.

Jovanni:

There's imagination.

Jovanni:

It's a tourist

Lia Tarachansky:

destination.

Lia Tarachansky:

Yeah, in

Jovanni:

the imaginations of most Americans is that we're just,

Jovanni:

oh, we're all about beaches.

Jovanni:

That's what we're all about.

Jovanni:

Beaches, just having just relaxing on the beach.

Jovanni:

That's all we do all day, but yeah, there is that chauvinism.

Jovanni:

On Puerto Ricans.

Jovanni:

But yeah, so there there's differences with, between the, Puerto Rican and

Jovanni:

population and Palestinian population is the fact we're not receiving the

Jovanni:

violence that Palestinians are getting.

Jovanni:

Right now we did at one point in the 1950s, we did get the colonial violence.

Jovanni:

Puerto Rico was bombed by the U.

Jovanni:

S.

Jovanni:

Air Force in the 1950s, the time of the fallujahs when we had an

Jovanni:

uprising then in 1950s but today we don't see the same violence

Jovanni:

that the Palestinians are getting.

Jovanni:

However there is the, one of the biggest difference that I've seen with

Jovanni:

Palestinians between Puerto Ricans and Puerto Ricans is that there are, there

Jovanni:

is a portion of Puerto Ricans who have adopted this Americanism identity.

Jovanni:

They feel more, more American than they do in Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

And you see the estadistas, which is the statehooders.

Jovanni:

And that's one of the things that divide the Puerto Rican community,

Jovanni:

which is the pro statehooders.

Jovanni:

And the Independentista, which is the independence of people and whatnot.

Jovanni:

We just had an election, too, yesterday.

Jovanni:

And you can see the state voters just fly American flags everywhere in Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

And they shunned this tent.

Jovanni:

When I was growing up in Puerto Rico, flying the Puerto Rican flag was

Jovanni:

shunned upon by them, because you're seen as, As a, what do you call it, a

Jovanni:

comunista, a communist, you're seen as a nacionalista, nationalist and people

Jovanni:

will say things like, you can't, Puerto Rico can't get independence because

Jovanni:

then we'll starve if we get independence from the United States, stuff like that.

Jovanni:

We can't run, we can't run anything here, we can't even run the post office,

Jovanni:

if we're going to run the post office, we'll never get packages, your comments.

Jovanni:

So

Lia Tarachansky:

if you are not, so if you're not an American imperialist,

Lia Tarachansky:

you're considered a separatist?

Jovanni:

Yes.

Lia Tarachansky:

And were you, are you, do you come from an imperialist

Lia Tarachansky:

family or separatist family?

Jovanni:

No, or do you not

Lia Tarachansky:

see it as so black and white?

Jovanni:

So my dad is Dominican from the Dominican Republic.

Jovanni:

My dad did survive an American invasion of his country in 1965.

Jovanni:

So he was a child.

Jovanni:

He was about 13 years old when the United States invaded the

Jovanni:

Dominican Republic in 1965.

Jovanni:

My mom, she's Puerto Rican and she's from the countryside.

Jovanni:

Mostly people from the countryside tend to be more, more attached to

Jovanni:

to Puerto Rico than people from more urban areas and whatnot,

Lia Tarachansky:

do you see yourself as indigenous to Puerto Rico?

Jovanni:

I consider myself descendant to indigeneity because we have the disconnect

Jovanni:

of, we have 400 years of colonialism.

Jovanni:

We have adopted Things in our culture, in our language that are indigenous, but

Jovanni:

most of us don't even know we have to do the research to know that what we've been

Jovanni:

saying all these years is actually the origins is indigenous, but we never knew,

Jovanni:

what we eat today from the Taino people were the indigenous people of Puerto

Jovanni:

Rico, but we never knew because we weren't really taught that, so this research

Jovanni:

is going on to recover that identity, but I consider myself a descendant.

Jovanni:

Of the Taino people and also descended of the Afro people

Jovanni:

that came to the island as well.

Lia Tarachansky:

You mean the Africans who were enslaved and dragged to the Americas?

Jovanni:

Yes.

Lia Tarachansky:

When we first met, you told me something that absolutely

Lia Tarachansky:

shook me to the core when I was asking you and your partner about Indigeneity

Lia Tarachansky:

in Puerto Rico, you said the indigenous people now only live in our genes.

Jovanni:

Yes.

Jovanni:

I was wondering if

Lia Tarachansky:

you could elaborate on that.

Jovanni:

There was a study that was done saying that 60 percent of

Jovanni:

Puerto Ricans, carry the chromosome, the genes of the Taino people.

Jovanni:

60%.

Jovanni:

But the

Lia Tarachansky:

Taino people don't exist in Puerto Rico anymore.

Jovanni:

Yeah, I guess they exist in us.

Jovanni:

So

Lia Tarachansky:

they were basically genocided.

Jovanni:

Exactly.

Lia Tarachansky:

And their genocide for you, I'm assuming this is part of why you

Lia Tarachansky:

are so personally implicated and implicate yourself in anti genocidal movements.

Jovanni:

Yes, that sounds right, correct.

Lia Tarachansky:

So you are an anti imperialist, you're against

Lia Tarachansky:

indigenous genocide, you grow up reading Malcolm X, and you have this

Lia Tarachansky:

history of enslavement in your family.

Lia Tarachansky:

How do you end up in the American military?

Jovanni:

My dad was in the military.

Jovanni:

Like I said, my dad came to the United States in the 70s.

Jovanni:

He was, I think he was like 18 when he came.

Jovanni:

He was after the revolution in 65.

Jovanni:

His oldest sister was a domestic at a wealthy family, wealthy Dominican family.

Jovanni:

And at a time in 19 after the revolution, a lot of the wealthy, the bourgeoisie

Jovanni:

and Dominican public thought that the Dominican public would go the way of Cuba.

Jovanni:

We have a Cuban revolution and just like revolution, et cetera.

Jovanni:

So many of the middle class and wealthy just packed and left.

Jovanni:

Went to New York, and my aunt went with the family.

Jovanni:

She was a domestic in that family, and they took her to New York,

Jovanni:

and that was in the late 60s.

Jovanni:

Then when my aunt got her documents and everything, she facilitated my

Jovanni:

father to come to the United States.

Jovanni:

He's the youngest of the siblings, so it was easier for her to do

Jovanni:

because she was the youngest.

Jovanni:

He was in New York in the seventies and did a lot of job.

Jovanni:

He went to factories.

Jovanni:

He met my mom.

Jovanni:

He worked in the taxi he was a mechanic, et cetera.

Jovanni:

Then he joined the National Guard and afterwards, moved to Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

He was in the National Guard in Puerto Rico for a while,

Jovanni:

and then he joined active duty.

Jovanni:

So we ended up going different places.

Jovanni:

And then we went back to Puerto Rico, then we went to Virginia, in Virginia

Jovanni:

that's one of the things that got me interested in war and conflicts, because

Jovanni:

when I got to Virginia, it was in 19 89, I got to Virginia and that year,

Jovanni:

we used to live in a military base.

Jovanni:

And that year was the invasion of Panama.

Jovanni:

So I got to see all the soldiers leave to Panama, to the invasion of Panama

Jovanni:

from that base and then come back.

Jovanni:

Then 18 months later, that's when the war against Iraq started in 1990.

Jovanni:

These same soldiers are all left.

Jovanni:

And went to the Gulf and then came back.

Jovanni:

So that pretty much intrigued me about conflicts and following

Jovanni:

wars and stuff like that.

Jovanni:

So ever since that, pretty much left an impression in me.

Lia Tarachansky:

In my country, in Israel, being part of the

Lia Tarachansky:

military, it's mandatory.

Lia Tarachansky:

And some people they don't, they decide not to go for political or personal

Lia Tarachansky:

reasons so much that they are willing to go to jail to not go to the Israeli army.

Lia Tarachansky:

But you don't see Palestinians almost.

Lia Tarachansky:

Almost non existent for Palestinians to join the Israeli army.

Lia Tarachansky:

However, Bedouins in the south of what is today Israel do join

Lia Tarachansky:

the Israeli army to some extent.

Lia Tarachansky:

How do you explain this as a victim of American imperialism being a Puerto Rico?

Lia Tarachansky:

How do you explain to the rest of the world why victims of American

Lia Tarachansky:

imperialism would then go and join the American imperialist army?

Jovanni:

That's something that was intriguing me as well because in the

Jovanni:

military I've seen a lot of people that were the people in the military, though,

Jovanni:

I had an instructor at one point, he was Vietnamese, he was one of my instructors,

Jovanni:

so I've seen a lot of people, I see a lot of Koreans, I see a lot of people

Jovanni:

that were, that has felt The other end of the muzzle, the other end of the

Jovanni:

rifle of the American imperialism get destroyed and then join the military.

Jovanni:

I've seen a lot of, there's a lot of Arabs in the military, a lot of, I've seen

Jovanni:

Iraqis join the American military, and their countries got destroyed, so that's

Jovanni:

something that's always intrigued me.

Jovanni:

I don't really understand that.

Lia Tarachansky:

You joined.

Lia Tarachansky:

Why did you join?

Jovanni:

I joined because as a teen, that was most of my,

Jovanni:

I lived in a military base.

Jovanni:

Most of my friends were soldiers and that's something

Jovanni:

everybody did after high school.

Lia Tarachansky:

And you met your partner in the army.

Jovanni:

Yes.

Lia Tarachansky:

Is she also a child of American soldiers?

Jovanni:

Oh, no she left.

Jovanni:

She joined from Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

That was the first time leaving Puerto Rico, actually.

Lia Tarachansky:

So she knew she wanted to be part of the army.

Jovanni:

No, it was just, she was in college actually at the time and

Jovanni:

then she just, it's something, a recruiter came up and sweetened a

Jovanni:

deal and whatnot and she was young and she just joined the military.

Lia Tarachansky:

Do you see any cultural difference between the American military

Lia Tarachansky:

and the average American citizenry?

Jovanni:

I do.

Jovanni:

What is the cultural difference?

Jovanni:

I see a sort of caste, a military caste.

Jovanni:

In the United States, and it's an esceptic cast because the average

Jovanni:

American get propagandized on how awesome the military is and how much

Jovanni:

you have to respect the military.

Jovanni:

And every football game parades of jets flying over, over the stadium and in

Jovanni:

every sports arena military people.

Jovanni:

So we're given this persona.

Jovanni:

We're beyond reproach, and then we're just like a super citizen, this image that you

Jovanni:

have to look at us in awe, so I see this division between the Arab civilian, the

Jovanni:

military only makes about 1 percent of the population in the United States, and it's

Jovanni:

320 million people in the United States, only 1 percent are in the military so you

Jovanni:

have the majority of Americans are not in the military and, They're fed with this

Jovanni:

culture, this awesomeness of militarism, and every time you tell someone that,

Jovanni:

you're a veteran and whatnot, the first thing, reflexively, they tell you is,

Jovanni:

thank you for your service, that happened with the Iraq War, because before it

Jovanni:

wasn't like that, but then during the Iraq War, everybody, tell them you're in the

Jovanni:

military or you're veteran reflexively tell you thank you for your service.

Jovanni:

So I see that.

Lia Tarachansky:

Did you serve in Iraq?

Jovanni:

Did I serve in Iraq?

Jovanni:

No, I refused.

Lia Tarachansky:

So how does it feel for you to be thanked for your service?

Jovanni:

It feels weird because I know that I didn't serve, for example, I

Jovanni:

think about when people say thank you for your service, for serving in Iraq.

Jovanni:

And my thought is, how, in what way did Iraq threaten you?

Jovanni:

In what way would your freedoms would be, which freedom did you defend?

Jovanni:

Or would have been taken away from you if we haven't invaded Iraq, in the service

Lia Tarachansky:

of what?

Jovanni:

Yeah, what are we serving?

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Lia Tarachansky:

So you said you refused to go to the Iraq

Lia Tarachansky:

war, so what were you doing?

Lia Tarachansky:

Why did you decide to refuse?

Lia Tarachansky:

Because,

Jovanni:

the reason I refused, because when I left the military,

Jovanni:

I was already a careerist.

Jovanni:

What does

Lia Tarachansky:

that mean?

Jovanni:

That when you're in the military, you can retire with 20 years.

Jovanni:

And you get a pension, I did 12 years.

Jovanni:

I was already careerist.

Jovanni:

And I could have just waited out the last seven years and would have pension.

Jovanni:

And your

Lia Tarachansky:

partner, did she serve in Iraq?

Jovanni:

No, she only did three years.

Jovanni:

She did three years and she got out.

Jovanni:

And how would you feel if

Lia Tarachansky:

your son decided to go to the American army?

Jovanni:

How do I feel?

Jovanni:

I'll be disappointed.

Jovanni:

Why?

Jovanni:

It's the choice

Lia Tarachansky:

you made.

Jovanni:

Yeah, I'll be disappointed.

Jovanni:

Yeah, he has a little bit more education as far as the military than I did.

Jovanni:

When I joined, we were considered like a peacetime military, and this country

Jovanni:

has been at war his entire life, and it's funny, I did deploy to Bosnia

Jovanni:

when the destruction of Yugoslavia.

Jovanni:

And I was a young man and our unit was actually the first units that put boots

Jovanni:

on the ground in Bosnia and Croatia.

Jovanni:

And it wasn't until years later.

Jovanni:

That I started reading and analyzing, what happened in

Jovanni:

Yugoslavia, why we're in Yugoslavia.

Jovanni:

And I feel that most soldiers, most people that join the military don't have that

Jovanni:

analysis, don't understand, what happens.

Jovanni:

Like I said, they don't know what happened.

Jovanni:

They don't know what's beyond their borders.

Jovanni:

Most people, most young kids don't really know.

Jovanni:

They just, they're sold that, you can get ahead, you get college money.

Jovanni:

You'd be respected in the community, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.

Jovanni:

It's depoliticized.

Jovanni:

Your participation in the military, it's more about you,

Jovanni:

it's more about your advancement, your career and stuff like that.

Jovanni:

Whereas in Israel, I believe, I've never been to Israel, but I believe

Jovanni:

that the Israeli young soldier know what they're getting into.

Jovanni:

They know that their country is in a state of war.

Lia Tarachansky:

The average Israeli, first of all, Doesn't think about

Lia Tarachansky:

not going to the army because it's virtually unheard of, at least in

Lia Tarachansky:

my, I grew up in a settlement, every single person went to the army.

Lia Tarachansky:

Not going to the army is considered so radical outside of the norm of society.

Lia Tarachansky:

And, You say anybody pulls up social media, they can see

Lia Tarachansky:

what's going on in Palestine.

Lia Tarachansky:

You're seeing little bits of what's going on in Gaza and in the West Bank.

Lia Tarachansky:

But when you grow up in Israel, you don't see anything at all.

Lia Tarachansky:

And the soldiers who perpetrate war crimes don't tend to talk about those things.

Lia Tarachansky:

They're considered taboo.

Lia Tarachansky:

So every generation of soldiers thinks that they're going out there.

Lia Tarachansky:

to defend from this like sea of hostile enemies and you know the average person

Lia Tarachansky:

at least my age grew up during the second intifada when a lot of people

Lia Tarachansky:

were getting blown up at cafes and killed on the bus and terrorism was a very

Lia Tarachansky:

big part of daily violence for us and so it became like of course I'm going

Lia Tarachansky:

to grow up and I'm going to go defend my homeland against these people who

Lia Tarachansky:

are trying to kill us and once they get trained and they get the weapons and

Lia Tarachansky:

they learn how to use them and they get sent It takes years before they actually

Lia Tarachansky:

understand, Oh God, we are the aggressors.

Lia Tarachansky:

And that's only if they understand that.

Lia Tarachansky:

Most people finish the army, they do horrific things and they try

Lia Tarachansky:

to never think about it again.

Lia Tarachansky:

And it takes a total fundamental foundational disruption for a person to

Lia Tarachansky:

understand that actually we're not the victims or we're not just the victims of

Lia Tarachansky:

this reality, we're also its co creators.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I'm wondering like right now During the George W.

Lia Tarachansky:

Bush years, the war in Iraq and Afghanistan was such a central

Lia Tarachansky:

part of American politics.

Lia Tarachansky:

What wars are you fighting right now?

Jovanni:

The war in Palestine, not an American war, the war in Ukraine as

Jovanni:

American war is the Western War at.

Jovanni:

You mentioned the conflict in the Congo, for example, a lot of those militias

Jovanni:

are getting support from the West that's happening in the Congo, right?

Jovanni:

I think you also know that Israel also supports a lot of the militias

Jovanni:

and whatnot, in Africa as well.

Jovanni:

On both

Lia Tarachansky:

sides.

Jovanni:

Yeah, both sides.

Jovanni:

Yes, so all these wars, all these wars, and then you have the buildup

Jovanni:

of hostility in Taiwan now, Taiwan is being armed up to the teeth now.

Jovanni:

It's a focal point now, it's a tinderbox for conflict there as well.

Jovanni:

So all these wars, see what happened is with the Iraq war.

Jovanni:

With the Iraq war, it was a show of force.

Jovanni:

It wasn't just, it wasn't about Iraq.

Jovanni:

It was a show of force to show the awesomeness.

Jovanni:

Of the American military.

Jovanni:

That was the idea and the way it was sold to

Lia Tarachansky:

establish dominance, as the Israeli army calls it.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Jovanni:

And we call it, they call it here the full specter dominance.

Jovanni:

The Americans wanted to do full specter dominance of air, land, sea space,

Jovanni:

outer space, cyber, and all that.

Jovanni:

They wanted to show the awesomeness of the American military.

Jovanni:

And then the fact that the planes hit.

Jovanni:

The towers and that was a humiliation that was seen as the United States had

Jovanni:

to show that can never happen again.

Jovanni:

It was like slave time.

Jovanni:

If there was a slave that rebelled against the plantation owner and stuff like that.

Jovanni:

He was made an example of, right?

Jovanni:

He was all the other slaves had to come out and have to view and have

Jovanni:

to witness the punishment of this particular slave and punish him in some

Jovanni:

gruesome way, and so everyone can see.

Jovanni:

So no one could dare do that again.

Jovanni:

And that was the thing about the U.

Jovanni:

S.

Jovanni:

military when they invaded Iraq and Afghanistan.

Jovanni:

And in both situations, they were defeated.

Jovanni:

They were defeated in Afghanistan for 20 years, and they were defeated in

Jovanni:

Iraq as well, the military, right?

Jovanni:

After that, Obama came with the policy of leading from behind.

Jovanni:

No longer would the American people tolerate boots on the ground and

Jovanni:

having all these casualties coming in boxes and stuff like that with

Jovanni:

the media and stuff like that.

Jovanni:

So now we sacrifice other people.

Jovanni:

So you do proxy wars.

Jovanni:

So right now you want, we want to attack Russia, but we don't want to

Jovanni:

attack Russia in front to attack Russia.

Jovanni:

So we use Ukraine to attack Russia.

Jovanni:

We want to attack China, but won't engage in China.

Jovanni:

We use Taiwan to attack China, stuff like that.

Jovanni:

So it's more about.

Jovanni:

It's more and then we'll send this assets because there is assets, there is military

Jovanni:

assets in Israel right now, special forces people and they're using Crete to to

Jovanni:

supply the Israeli army and stuff like that, but you won't see a big bulk of

Jovanni:

military people boots on the ground for a long time because the American people.

Jovanni:

Won't support, having their young kids coming back in boxes, because of

Jovanni:

the Iraq war and the Afghanistan war.

Lia Tarachansky:

If Kamala were to win the presidency, being a woman,

Lia Tarachansky:

first and foremost, she would have had to illustrate to her opponents

Lia Tarachansky:

that she is a militaristically minded person who is willing to do whatever

Lia Tarachansky:

it takes to drag America out of its global reputation now as a has been.

Lia Tarachansky:

And of course, it's not a very big leap to know that if she was elected,

Lia Tarachansky:

she would have had to start at least some kind of a war, most likely in

Lia Tarachansky:

the Middle East, or significantly increase American presence, let's say,

Lia Tarachansky:

in Palestine or Lebanon or in Taiwan.

Lia Tarachansky:

Considering she didn't win the election, what do you think a Trump presidency, what

Lia Tarachansky:

kind of effect do you think it's going to have on American global imperialism?

Jovanni:

I think there's very little change.

Jovanni:

The United States right now with One of the changes that could happen

Jovanni:

with Trump the defunding of and the closing out of the war in Ukraine.

Jovanni:

That could be a possibility of a political settlement there.

Jovanni:

And that could come to a close, either a frozen conflict

Jovanni:

would just come to a close.

Jovanni:

Right now the Democrats wasn't allowing and the British wasn't allowing.

Jovanni:

For the violence in Ukraine and between Ukraine and Russia to stop because

Jovanni:

their idea was to weaken Russia.

Jovanni:

That's what they want, weaken Russia and they were willing to sacrifice.

Jovanni:

Whole lots of Ukrainians to do I think Trump can deescalate, has the potential

Jovanni:

to deescalate the situation in Ukraine.

Jovanni:

But with the situation in, in, in West Asia, it's a little bit different

Jovanni:

because one of the constituents of the Trump administration are

Jovanni:

evangelical Christians as well.

Jovanni:

And the evangelical Christians in the United States have this

Jovanni:

personal attachment to, or this emotional attachment to Israel.

Jovanni:

And that's one of the huge constituents.

Jovanni:

Religious

Lia Tarachansky:

attachment.

Jovanni:

And also here in the United States, we've been culturated to always

Jovanni:

give Israel the benefit of the doubt.

Jovanni:

And we're attached to the Holocaust and all that.

Jovanni:

And then Iran's this big boogeyman that wants to kill us all.

Jovanni:

I think with that situation and the United States has been resistant because

Jovanni:

I know that's one of the policies of Bin Netanyahu to dry in the West United

Jovanni:

States to confront Iran for a long time.

Jovanni:

That, that's been one of the policies to try to dry in, to take Iran out

Jovanni:

as a competitor or as a threat, as to Israel dominance in the area.

Jovanni:

And when Biden sent all those warships to the Mediterranean and stuff like

Jovanni:

that, but they've been resisting.

Jovanni:

Kamala probably depending how the situation with the WR goes down,

Jovanni:

I know R'S talking about reacting to the recent bombings that the

Jovanni:

recent incursion that the Israel conducted, I think was 1st of October.

Jovanni:

They're talking about retaliating, depending on what goes down there

Jovanni:

would've been a possibility that the Kamala would've

Jovanni:

authorized boots the ground.

Jovanni:

It, depends how much of a threat Israel finds itself with the

Jovanni:

Iranian retaliation, I believe.

Jovanni:

But there is boots on the ground.

Jovanni:

It sounds

Lia Tarachansky:

like in a zero sum way of thinking, your understanding is that

Lia Tarachansky:

a Trump presidency is actually good for reducing American imperialism globally.

Jovanni:

I think it needs Europe.

Jovanni:

I think with Iran in West Asia the potential is still there.

Jovanni:

It's a tinderbox.

Jovanni:

The potential is still there for Trump to engage in frontal conflict with Iran.

Jovanni:

You got to think about Iran.

Jovanni:

Trump assassinated one of the top general, General Soleimani, right?

Jovanni:

It was because of Iranian restraint that we didn't go into

Jovanni:

an actual conflict with Iran.

Jovanni:

They retaliated to a couple of American bases in Iraq, and that was it.

Jovanni:

But it was a huge thing, assassinating a top general, right?

Jovanni:

It could have been a potential war with Iran.

Jovanni:

But yeah, stuff like that, recklessness like that, Trump

Jovanni:

would have got us into a conflict.

Jovanni:

There's a frozen conflict in the Korean peninsula.

Jovanni:

It's been over over the world by 60 years now, with North Korea.

Jovanni:

And there were gestures in the first Trump administration to

Jovanni:

bring that conflict to a close.

Jovanni:

There's a frozen conflict, a tinderbox as well nuclear armament involved.

Jovanni:

And there some gestures to bring it to a close.

Jovanni:

Trump met the North Korean lead, I think twice.

Jovanni:

He was sabotaged by his own people in his cabinet, Mike Pompeo and

Jovanni:

John Bolton which his own appointees and by the Democratic Party.

Jovanni:

And he didn't go anywhere.

Jovanni:

He didn't lead.

Jovanni:

Yeah, I'm thinking East Asia for

Lia Tarachansky:

sure.

Lia Tarachansky:

And do you think the, sorry, go ahead.

Lia Tarachansky:

I

Jovanni:

think East Asia East Europe for sure, there's a huge potential

Jovanni:

that Trump wind that conflict down.

Jovanni:

But in West Asia.

Lia Tarachansky:

In terms of the global chess board, the bursky type

Lia Tarachansky:

of idea of the global chess board, you do see a Trump administration

Lia Tarachansky:

as less destructive to the world.

Jovanni:

With Russia, yes.

Lia Tarachansky:

And what do you think is the impact of this second

Lia Tarachansky:

Trump administration on Puerto Rico?

Jovanni:

If you recall, Puerto Rico right now is, we've lost about a

Jovanni:

half a million people in the last 10 to 20 years to migration to the

Jovanni:

United States because of the economic depression in Puerto Rico, right?

Jovanni:

You go to, last time I was in Puerto Rico, you see a lot of dilapidated

Jovanni:

buildings even though they're trying to restore it for tourism and whatnot,

Jovanni:

but you see a lot of empty buildings, you see a lot of people leaving the

Jovanni:

island because of the economic hardship.

Jovanni:

But at the same time, you see a lot of Americans, wealthy Americans moving

Jovanni:

into Puerto Rico, buying up land.

Jovanni:

Building, buying up stuff like that.

Jovanni:

It's just speculating.

Jovanni:

Speculating in capital and stuff like that over there.

Jovanni:

The Bitcoin people going over there and whatnot.

Jovanni:

And we had, during the Trump era, we had Hurricane Maria, which

Jovanni:

was a devastating hurricane.

Jovanni:

We haven't had a hurricane like that since 1901, 1903, something like that, right?

Jovanni:

Which is Hurricane San Ciriaco, and it's estimated about 3, 000

Jovanni:

people perished in that hurricane.

Jovanni:

Puerto Ricans and whatnot.

Lia Tarachansky:

And what was Trump's, he was president at the time.

Lia Tarachansky:

What was his reaction to Hurricane Maria?

Jovanni:

His response was very delayed, very mild, there were people that went

Jovanni:

through a whole year without power.

Jovanni:

Without electrical power, the aid trickled after he got pressured to

Jovanni:

put aid and one of his comments was, because at the same time there was a

Jovanni:

hurricane here in Texas as well, I think it was Harvey or something like that.

Jovanni:

And he said that Harvey, that Texas, Harvey was a more priority because

Jovanni:

they voted for him, not Puerto Ricans.

Jovanni:

That's one of the things that he said openly.

Jovanni:

And also we have the Jones Act.

Jovanni:

The Jones Act is a 19th century act on Puerto Rico that only allows foreign

Jovanni:

ships can't dock in Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

They have to go to Florida first, and then they have to be unloaded

Jovanni:

and put in American ship and then brought to Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

So there were countries that tried to bring aid to Puerto Rico.

Jovanni:

They weren't allowed to dock in Puerto Rico to bring aid.

Jovanni:

You had to be pressured to lift the Jones for about 10 days, I

Jovanni:

believe, or something like that.

Jovanni:

So he lifted it for 10 days, to let the bring in supply and whatnot.

Jovanni:

But yeah, so it was very destructive and it's funny you say that because in Puerto

Jovanni:

Rico, there's a lot of single fans, a lot of Trump single fans in Puerto Rico too.

Jovanni:

Those stakeholders I was telling you about, like there,

Jovanni:

there's a lot of single fans.

Jovanni:

The governor, the one that got elected yesterday as governor,

Jovanni:

her name is Jennifer Gonzalez.

Jovanni:

She's a Trump single fan.

Jovanni:

So it's funny that the amnesia of people,

Lia Tarachansky:

are you a Trump fan?

Jovanni:

Oh, no.

Jovanni:

So

Lia Tarachansky:

what.

Lia Tarachansky:

I'm asking that facetiously because I feel that in my circle of friends,

Lia Tarachansky:

I can't talk about my feelings on Trump because obviously I see him as a

Lia Tarachansky:

buffoon, I see him as a sexist, I see him as a racist, or at least he acts

Lia Tarachansky:

in ways that support racism and sexism.

Lia Tarachansky:

But as a person who is an Israeli and pro Palestinian to that extent

Lia Tarachansky:

that I've dedicated my life to ending Israeli colonialism, I

Lia Tarachansky:

do see that Trump is a buffoon.

Lia Tarachansky:

would be less destructive to us than Kamala, even though I

Lia Tarachansky:

have a lot of empathy for his antisocial policies in America.

Lia Tarachansky:

I'm so terrified of yet another American war in the Middle East

Lia Tarachansky:

because every American little political game costs the Middle East

Lia Tarachansky:

hundreds of thousands of people.

Lia Tarachansky:

And yet here you are, a man of the left, a man who has read all the

Lia Tarachansky:

ideological forefathers that self respected leftists should read.

Lia Tarachansky:

Here you are saying basically that even from inside America, that

Lia Tarachansky:

you see things in a similar way.

Lia Tarachansky:

And, I teach some university courses and my students don't,

Lia Tarachansky:

They don't read those texts.

Lia Tarachansky:

They don't do the research.

Lia Tarachansky:

They don't get inspired.

Lia Tarachansky:

They maybe watch a biographical movie about MLK, but they would never

Lia Tarachansky:

sit down and read, the biography of Malcolm X as written by Alex

Lia Tarachansky:

Haley, for example, there's a real bend in the new generation, an anti

Lia Tarachansky:

ideological bend, a desire to dismiss.

Lia Tarachansky:

Those big ideological struggles of Marxism, Leninism, Socialism,

Lia Tarachansky:

Capitalism, because in this late stage capitalist postmodern world that

Lia Tarachansky:

we live in, it doesn't even matter.

Lia Tarachansky:

Has your son read the books that you read?

Lia Tarachansky:

And if he has?

Lia Tarachansky:

What kind of conversations do you have at home about the political ideologies

Lia Tarachansky:

that drive your political dedications?

Jovanni:

No, he hasn't, unfortunately.

Jovanni:

I try to get him to read certain books, and it's very hard, like you said,

Jovanni:

because there's So much that his kids do, and there's so much influence

Jovanni:

that there is out there, he's more of the TikTok generation, where most

Jovanni:

of his information comes from TikTok unfortunately and going back to the

Jovanni:

generation you're talking about the generation is very impatient it takes a

Jovanni:

lot of patience to sit down and read a book from cover to cover, it takes a lot

Jovanni:

of dedication to do that, and discipline to do that We have a generation that's

Jovanni:

like a microwave generations everything has to be instant gratification.

Jovanni:

It's hard for people to sit down and absorb all that.

Jovanni:

So a quick fix is a bio, a biographer movie or a TikTok video and that seems to

Jovanni:

be story for a lot of these young people.

Lia Tarachansky:

Let's operate with data.

Lia Tarachansky:

Let's say you are teaching a course to this new generation.

Lia Tarachansky:

What do you think in a TikTok way, what do you think would

Lia Tarachansky:

be the legacy of someone like.

Lia Tarachansky:

Malcolm X or Fred Hampton.

Lia Tarachansky:

What do you think they would say?

Lia Tarachansky:

What would you think Satya Shakur want to say?

Lia Tarachansky:

What would be the people who really formed your ideological positions

Lia Tarachansky:

that moved you to dedicate your entire adult life to political organizing?

Lia Tarachansky:

What do you think those great thinkers, what would they say?

Lia Tarachansky:

What would be their legacy?

Lia Tarachansky:

What would you say is the essence, the distilled version of their message

Lia Tarachansky:

to the young generation, to your son?

Jovanni:

That's a it'll have, from an educational perspective, in order

Jovanni:

to instill that, I think it has to be brought into, in a conversational

Jovanni:

way, bring those young people you're talking about in a conversational way

Jovanni:

And have them participate in their own learning, their own exploration.

Jovanni:

Ask more of a Socratic questionings and try, I don't know, Lia.

Jovanni:

It's just difficult.

Jovanni:

Yeah,

Lia Tarachansky:

it's tough.

Lia Tarachansky:

We deal with it constantly.

Lia Tarachansky:

How do you keep attention?

Lia Tarachansky:

I find that to me, I don't see the new generation as being impatient.

Lia Tarachansky:

What I see is that the new generation doesn't see the reason

Lia Tarachansky:

for why they should do this.

Lia Tarachansky:

Like for me, I was reading, I was picking up those books because I felt at their

Lia Tarachansky:

age that I was being lied to, that my world was not the real world, that I

Lia Tarachansky:

was being represented the world through a set of ideologies that are not true.

Lia Tarachansky:

And when I started to pick at that a lot of the foundations for what

Lia Tarachansky:

I thought was true started to fall apart, and that was so unnerving,

Lia Tarachansky:

I had to find my own answers.

Lia Tarachansky:

Whereas the new generation grows up in a world where there's truth

Lia Tarachansky:

and there's not truth, that there's not truths and it's a post factual

Lia Tarachansky:

world that doesn't really matter.

Lia Tarachansky:

Yeah, it doesn't matter what you grew up believing is true or not

Lia Tarachansky:

true, because nothing really matters.

Lia Tarachansky:

And they don't see the real reason for why they should educate

Lia Tarachansky:

themselves outside of the real world.

Lia Tarachansky:

Whatever degree is going to give them a job that's going to pay for their bills.

Lia Tarachansky:

What is for a lot of my students, and of course, my students are just

Lia Tarachansky:

as curious as we were at their age.

Lia Tarachansky:

They're just as motivated to make the world a better

Lia Tarachansky:

place as we were at their age.

Lia Tarachansky:

But they don't see the point of why they should sit down and read some guy

Lia Tarachansky:

who wrote some stuff about stuff that's no longer relevant to their lives.

Lia Tarachansky:

50 years ago.

Lia Tarachansky:

So who do you think are the thinkers of today that young people could read that

Lia Tarachansky:

would make sense to their lives today?

Lia Tarachansky:

Who do you go to when you try to understand what's going on today?

Jovanni:

I go to the old texts.

Jovanni:

I read for example, when it comes to Latin America, I read Galeano.

Jovanni:

We wrote about Latin America, the La Vena Sabieta, América Latina,

Jovanni:

Open Bases of Latin America, I read Fidel's writings to the old text.

Jovanni:

I'm starting read to the Foundations I just started to

Jovanni:

read alien Puppet about Israel.

Lia Tarachansky:

And have you had a chance to read Tenah Hase

Lia Tarachansky:

Coates's new book about Palestine?

Jovanni:

No, but I saw the whole controversy about it,

Jovanni:

so I'm curious, have you,

Lia Tarachansky:

I haven't read the book, but I heard him talk about

Lia Tarachansky:

it in various lengthy interviews, especially one made by Trevor Noah.

Lia Tarachansky:

Very good interview because Trevor Noah actually lets him speak and actually

Lia Tarachansky:

asks him questions that motivate him to speak about what he wrote about and why.

Lia Tarachansky:

And yeah, Alice Walker has done this in the past, Angelo Davis has

Lia Tarachansky:

done this in the past, and here, Tanya Hasecox, very incredible

Lia Tarachansky:

writer, thinker, connects the dots.

Lia Tarachansky:

Connects the apartheid of America to apartheid in Israel Palestine in a

Lia Tarachansky:

way that I think it's very necessary and speaks from a very personal

Lia Tarachansky:

place as a Black American, what it's like to experience apartheid

Lia Tarachansky:

with that's so visibly violent.

Lia Tarachansky:

Here in Canada, we have You might call the OG apartheid, the apartheid

Lia Tarachansky:

that informed the South African apartheid and later Israeli apartheid.

Lia Tarachansky:

When it comes to the dual system, there's the set of laws that

Lia Tarachansky:

apply to Canadian citizens.

Lia Tarachansky:

And then there's the set of laws known as the Indian Act and other legal structures

Lia Tarachansky:

that apply to the Native Americans.

Lia Tarachansky:

And there are two different legal systems that by and large has

Lia Tarachansky:

been incredibly destructive and genocidal to the indigenous people.

Lia Tarachansky:

And the system that those two systems created included very violent

Lia Tarachansky:

manifestations such as going out and killing people on preserve not

Lia Tarachansky:

fixing issues like access to clean water not connecting people to basic

Lia Tarachansky:

Things like, the grid and internet and accessible supply of resources.

Lia Tarachansky:

And then also genocide in terms of residential schools and the forbidding of

Lia Tarachansky:

cultural practices, languages, and so on.

Lia Tarachansky:

That system exists here and listening to Ta Nehisi Coates talk about what it's

Lia Tarachansky:

like to be a Black American in Palestine.

Lia Tarachansky:

To see apartheid manifest there resonated with me very well because I'm an Israeli

Lia Tarachansky:

in Canada and I'm seeing, both situations, and what that manifestation looks like.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I imagine for you as a person who grows up in Puerto Rico, and has

Lia Tarachansky:

these Very dedicated anti imperialist ideas that have inspired your

Lia Tarachansky:

entire creation for your whole life.

Lia Tarachansky:

Reading something that some, white academic wrote about settler

Lia Tarachansky:

colonialism is not as impactful as reading someone like Ta Nehisi

Lia Tarachansky:

Coates, who's writing from the same foundational texts you're talking about.

Lia Tarachansky:

And B is writing from personal experience.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Jovanni:

It's funny you say about Trevor Nora and you mentioned my son.

Jovanni:

He did read that book about him growing up in South Africa and

Jovanni:

he had a and Trevor Nora, right?

Jovanni:

The Trevor, no, yeah, the late night show host.

Jovanni:

So my son did have a lot of questions and a lot of and inspired him to

Jovanni:

look up South Africa and whatnot.

Lia Tarachansky:

That's amazing.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Jovanni:

So he needs to

Lia Tarachansky:

find his own Malcolm X.

Lia Tarachansky:

His own Alex Haley.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Lia Tarachansky:

I actually, I discovered Trevor Noah on a

Lia Tarachansky:

midnight bus between Durban and Pietermaritzburg in South Africa.

Lia Tarachansky:

It was a bus I took between those two cities and they were playing

Lia Tarachansky:

the 2011 Trevor Noah special.

Lia Tarachansky:

This was in 2011.

Lia Tarachansky:

And at the time, the whole bus.

Lia Tarachansky:

was in stitches because he was making fun of Zuma the president

Lia Tarachansky:

of South Africa at the time.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I remember thinking my God, this guy's hilarious.

Lia Tarachansky:

And also seeing a whole bunch of people at three o'clock in

Lia Tarachansky:

the morning, just in stitches.

Lia Tarachansky:

I was like, this guy's a great comedian.

Lia Tarachansky:

And then a few years later, he came to America.

Lia Tarachansky:

He's a really interesting thinker because he thinks quickly on his feet.

Lia Tarachansky:

He applies his personal biographical experience of apartheid to

Lia Tarachansky:

understanding the world.

Lia Tarachansky:

And because he speaks from different, completely different life experiences

Lia Tarachansky:

in different parts of the world, he's able to understand people in a way

Lia Tarachansky:

that a lot of other hosts are not.

Lia Tarachansky:

And to conclude.

Lia Tarachansky:

The questions I had for you, you set out to make this podcast, you set out to

Lia Tarachansky:

make these videos, these media project.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I was wondering, you have a very similar thing in terms of a

Lia Tarachansky:

lot of personal experience of the implication of the policies that

Lia Tarachansky:

you critique on your personal life.

Lia Tarachansky:

What is the project?

Lia Tarachansky:

What is your objective?

Lia Tarachansky:

What do you hope to achieve with this podcast that you created

Lia Tarachansky:

and all these people that you have interviewed over the years?

Jovanni:

At this point right now

Jovanni:

it's communication right now.

Jovanni:

I've only done this podcast two years now.

Jovanni:

This podcast has been going on for about five years, I believe, and I

Jovanni:

was invited in later on, and about two years now I think I'm going on.

Jovanni:

But it's offering perspective and offering conversations and, through conversation,

Jovanni:

people, you hope to educate people, hope to, like you said, open up windows

Jovanni:

and people not be so tunnel vision in one thing and just open up more and

Jovanni:

see other perspectives and whatnot.

Jovanni:

Just like you mentioned about Travis Noah, I grew up in different worlds.

Jovanni:

I grew up, here between the United States and Puerto Rico, Dominican Republic.

Jovanni:

I was in the military.

Jovanni:

I lived in Germany and Korea.

Jovanni:

I lived a year in Saudi Arabia.

Jovanni:

So I got different angles of different things.

Jovanni:

And while I was in those places, I always talked to local people and talked

Jovanni:

to people and it helped me a lot to see a lot of things in perspective.

Jovanni:

And hopefully one of the things that I set myself out also to open up perspective is

Jovanni:

as well, and people not be so focused on.

Jovanni:

On the, just their own lives, other things but the same token, one of the interviews

Jovanni:

I did here is how, I brought in a person, a totally depolitical person's not

Jovanni:

really, and it's just a person that, that goes to work day in and day out and is

Jovanni:

struggling through, because of the lack of healthcare that is here, and this person

Jovanni:

is actually is going through some rough time because of the lack of healthcare

Jovanni:

that's in this country, so I brought this person in to tell their story.

Jovanni:

And the connection that I try to do here is how much the fact that

Jovanni:

there's so much billions of dollars go overseas and to these war projects

Jovanni:

that it's hollowing out this country.

Jovanni:

And then just the average person, the average American just get left

Jovanni:

behind, so that's one of the things I like to connect, try to connect

Jovanni:

people, in this anti, anti imperialist journey I'm in is to connect the.

Jovanni:

The policies, the foreign policy with the domestic policy, bring it together and

Jovanni:

see how each, each influence the other.

Lia Tarachansky:

Excellent.

Lia Tarachansky:

Thank you so much, Jovanni.

Lia Tarachansky:

I I'm so glad I had a chance to get to know you even better.

Lia Tarachansky:

It was very fascinating to get to know you.

Lia Tarachansky:

I have a lot more questions about you as a person, but I think that maybe this

Lia Tarachansky:

is good for this very, very post Trump election day, very traumatic day as it is.

Jovanni:

Thank No, thank you for, I know, thank you for for taking the time and and

Jovanni:

interviewing me and bringing me those, those very insightful questions of yours.

Jovanni:

There was times you put me there you got me thinking that

Jovanni:

hard . But but I appreciate it.

Jovanni:

I appreciate you.

Lia Tarachansky:

It's called Revenge

Jovanni:

I appreciate it though.

Jovanni:

Thank you.

Jovanni:

Thank you for putting me in a spot and making me think.

Jovanni:

And it is very, it's very intellectually stimulating, when people, because not

Jovanni:

too often people ask you questions about you, and a lot of, the thoughts, you

Jovanni:

have it in your own mind, you don't have no one to share with, or you share with

Jovanni:

just in conversation, you write it down or whatever, but it's easier, but it's

Jovanni:

not often that you get people to ask you, you have to, you start grabbing, in

Jovanni:

your mind, try to put everything in some coherent word, and communicate, yeah.

Jovanni:

Yeah.

Lia Tarachansky:

It's like you said it's what you hope people would do is

Jovanni:

ask questions.

Jovanni:

Thank you, Lia.

Jovanni:

Thank you.

Jovanni:

And Lia, so before we leave what are you working on?

Jovanni:

And we're

Lia Tarachansky:

right now I'm just trying to not make a big mess out of

Lia Tarachansky:

my new teaching position at the Toronto Metropolitan University, but I'm

Lia Tarachansky:

trying to finish a documentary that's been a kind of my big white whale.

Lia Tarachansky:

It's a film that I started In 2017, about following a group of rabbis

Lia Tarachansky:

who have been trying very hard to transform the Israeli conflict from a

Lia Tarachansky:

political conflict to a religious one.

Lia Tarachansky:

And it's co directed with the incredible Dr.

Lia Tarachansky:

Rachel Feldman, who's a professor in America.

Lia Tarachansky:

And she actually wrote a book that got released this year about the topic.

Lia Tarachansky:

And over the course of these years, we followed these rabbis, we spent

Lia Tarachansky:

a lot of time interviewing them, spending time with their beliefs.

Lia Tarachansky:

They are what people might call the fundamentalist of the Jewish far and over

Lia Tarachansky:

the years, they went from the margins to the mainstream of Israeli society and

Lia Tarachansky:

ended up becoming members of parliament and rising all the way to the top.

Lia Tarachansky:

And as we are covering their big project in the most fragile part of the Middle

Lia Tarachansky:

East, or at least of Israel and Palestine, which is the Haram Aqsa, compound the

Lia Tarachansky:

Temple Mount, they have been trying to agitate and to provoke a religious

Lia Tarachansky:

war, and in the service of what they perceive to be an end of time prophecy.

Lia Tarachansky:

And what's going on today is a direct result of their struggles

Lia Tarachansky:

to agitate the public, the Palestinian public, into a conflict.

Lia Tarachansky:

And October 7th massacre that Hamas perpetrated in southern Israel was called

Lia Tarachansky:

the Al Aqsa flood because it is a direct response to what these rabbis have been

Lia Tarachansky:

doing at Al Aqsa at the Temple Mount.

Lia Tarachansky:

Basically it's a film about a movement of Jewish extremists that are trying

Lia Tarachansky:

to bring back biblical Judaism.

Lia Tarachansky:

And along the story of how we followed them and their project in Israel

Lia Tarachansky:

and Palestine, we actually ended up discovering that they have a global

Lia Tarachansky:

project and that took us to Mexico and the Philippines, and they're

Lia Tarachansky:

very active in Cameroon and in India.

Lia Tarachansky:

And I'm trying to get that film picked up by a producer and picked up by a

Lia Tarachansky:

broadcaster, but we got a bit of support in the beginning from The Guardian, but

Lia Tarachansky:

when the story grew and evolved into what it is it outgrew the short, the kind of

Lia Tarachansky:

shorts that The Guardian does, and so I've been trying to find a home for this film

Lia Tarachansky:

that is now halfway through production, It's such a complex piece and it's such a

Lia Tarachansky:

fire starter to talk about these things that it's been a real

Lia Tarachansky:

struggle to get this place a home.

Lia Tarachansky:

To supplement that, I've been working on a very cute project, a very small

Lia Tarachansky:

film with the co director Mary Bunch about these two elderly women in

Lia Tarachansky:

Quebec and Canada who are spending their retirement as former elementary

Lia Tarachansky:

school teachers planting 10, 000 trees.

Lia Tarachansky:

And so that's been a huge relief from all of these conflict driven film and genocide

Lia Tarachansky:

driven films to do a film about these two lovely women in their 80s who are spending

Lia Tarachansky:

every free minute planting 10, 000 trees.

Jovanni:

So cool.

Jovanni:

That's so cool.

Jovanni:

Oh thank you.

Jovanni:

Yeah, where can people find you?

Jovanni:

Where can people, follow your work?

Lia Tarachansky:

I'm at Liatorachansky.

Lia Tarachansky:

com.

Lia Tarachansky:

What about you?

Lia Tarachansky:

Where can people find you?

Lia Tarachansky:

What are you working on?

Lia Tarachansky:

Where can people find your work?

Jovanni:

I guess you can hear us portraits on the Hill podcast.

Jovanni:

You can see us in YouTube X Telegram whatever you can hear

Jovanni:

wherever you get podcasts from.

Jovanni:

Occasionally I write an article here and there.

Jovanni:

I just wrote an article recently.

Jovanni:

I posted a local paper about the upcoming veterans Day holiday,

Jovanni:

which is the 11th of November.

Jovanni:

And I wrote a quick article on it, where the Veterans Day come from,

Jovanni:

used to be Armistice Day and then how it was changed from Armistice Day to

Jovanni:

Veterans Day in the 1950s and the impact of it now, where people just really

Jovanni:

don't really think about the wars.

Jovanni:

Originally, it was to reflect on the First World War.

Jovanni:

But now people don't think about war.

Jovanni:

People just think about, the holiday specials and, time off and thanking

Jovanni:

a random veteran in the street.

Jovanni:

But, so it depoliticized the day, so that was, that's what the article is about.

Jovanni:

Yeah, so every now and then you can see my, I write an article every now and then.

Jovanni:

I haven't been as, I haven't been as active writing as I used

Jovanni:

to be, as I was before, though.

Lia Tarachansky:

I'm glad that article exists.

Jovanni:

Thank you and I'll thank everyone to, who joined us.

Jovanni:

And like I say, you can find us on YouTube, Ask the Telegram

Jovanni:

whatever you hear, podcasts like us share us with a friend.

Jovanni:

Yeah, please share us and stay tuned for our next episode.

Jovanni:

Take care.

Henri:

Money is tight these days for everyone, penny pinching to

Henri:

make it through the month often doesn't give people the funds to

Henri:

contribute to a creator they support.

Henri:

So we consider it the highest honor that folks help us fund the podcast

Henri:

in any dollar amount they're able.

Henri:

Patreon is the main place to do that.

Henri:

In addition, any support we receive makes sure we can continue to provide

Henri:

our main episodes free for everyone.

Henri:

And for supporters who can donate $10 a month or more, they will be listed

Henri:

right here as an honorary producer.

Henri:

Like these fine folks.

Henri:

Fahim's Everyone Dream, Eric Phillips, Paul Appel, Julie Dupree, Thomas Benson,

Henri:

Janet Hanson, Ren jacob, and Helge Berg.

Henri:

However, if Patreon isn't your style, you can contribute directly through PayPal

Henri:

at PayPal dot me forward slash Fortress on hill, or please check out our store on

Henri:

Spreadshirt for some great Fortress merch.

Henri:

We're on Twitter and @facebook.com at Fortress On A Hill.

Henri:

You can find our full collection of episodes at www dot

Henri:

Fortress On A Hill dot com.

Henri:

Skepticism is one's best armor.

Henri:

Never forget it.

Henri:

We'll see you next time.